Crypto Games ExtensionCrypto Games AppTelegram NewsSubmit
A whitehat is holding $320M in drained Bitcoin until Liquid proves it patched the flawImage Source: Cryptoslate

A whitehat is holding $320M in drained Bitcoin until Liquid proves it patched the flaw

George Tsagkarakis 3 min read
Contents 5 sections
We may include affiliate links in our content, meaning we could earn a commission—or receive blockchain-based assets—if you click a link and make a purchase or take a specific action. Additionally, we use generative AI to help draft and refine our posts for clarity and grammar. All content is fact-checked and reviewed by a human editor before publication.

At least 11 of Liquid’s 15 functionaries signed the transaction. That’s the number to sit with, according to blockchain security firm Bitslab, because it means nobody stole a key. Eleven independent signers looked at the same withdrawal and each one said yes.

The result was roughly $320 million in Bitcoin leaving the Liquid Network’s federation reserve through an abnormal peg-out, and a sidechain that stopped moving.

Liquid disabled its bridge nodes. SideSwap suspended swaps, peg-ins and peg-outs. Exchanges paused or prepared to pause L-BTC deposits and withdrawals while operators investigated.

Four thousand L-BTC that shouldn’t have existed

It started Sept. 6, when a customer sent 4,000 L-BTC to SideSwap’s peg-out service, the mechanism that converts Bitcoin represented on Liquid back into BTC on the main chain.

SideSwap said the request cleared the normal authorization process, and the Liquid Federation released about 3,996 BTC. That Bitcoin later landed at an address holding roughly 3,998.5 BTC at the latest check.

Liquid is built on a simple promise: one BTC held in the federation reserve for every L-BTC in circulation. A normal peg-out burns the L-BTC and releases an equivalent amount of Bitcoin.

Here the burn happened. The backing never did. SideSwap said a software bug created L-BTC with no Bitcoin behind it, and those tokens still walked through a valid peg-out, after which federation functionaries treated the withdrawal as legitimate and released real BTC.

SideSwap said Blockstream traced the 4,000 L-BTC presented for redemption to a flaw in Elements, the software Liquid runs on. If that holds up, the failure happened before anyone signed a Bitcoin transaction.

The keys worked exactly as designed

Both Liquid and SideSwap say no signing credentials were stolen. The withdrawal used SideSwap’s valid Peg-out Authorization Key, or PAK, and Liquid said neither that key nor other federation keys were compromised.

That makes this a different animal from the bridge hacks the industry has learned to pattern-match. Secure keys buy you very little when every signer is handed the same invalid state and accepts it.

No independent technical postmortem or detailed patch description was public at the latest check, which leaves the precise cause resting on what Liquid and SideSwap have said about it.

Timeline showing Liquid’s 4,000 L-BTC peg-out, 3,996 BTC payout, later 3,998.5 BTC movement, pause status and restart requirements.
A whitehat is holding $320M in drained Bitcoin until Liquid proves it patched the flaw 1 A whitehat is holding $320M in drained Bitcoin until Liquid proves it patched the flaw

Negotiating in OP_RETURN messages

The actors holding the Bitcoin identified themselves on-chain as “whitehats” and said they intended to return most of the funds once the underlying bug was fixed across the network. They’ve been talking to Blockstream through Bitcoin transactions carrying OP_RETURN messages.

Galaxy Digital research head Alex Thorn said Blockstream first sent a message asking the holder to contact its security team. The holder replied that it planned to send “most” of the Bitcoin back to the federation.

A later message attached a condition: Blockstream fixes the bug and confirms every node is patched, then the funds come back.

So the eventual financial loss may end up small. The question that stays open is how almost 4,000 BTC left the federation without an apparent key compromise.

Liquid Network White hat Hackers Communications With Blockstream
A whitehat is holding $320M in drained Bitcoin until Liquid proves it patched the flaw 2 A whitehat is holding $320M in drained Bitcoin until Liquid proves it patched the flaw

Patching is the easy half

Liquid has to find and fix the Elements flaw, push that fix to affected nodes, and then show that a second batch of invalid L-BTC can’t take the same path through authorization.

And it has to square the books. The allegedly bug-created L-BTC was burned on the way out, but about 3,996 real BTC left the federation wallet and hasn’t come back.

Until those funds return or the accounting is restored some other way, Liquid still owes the people holding legitimate L-BTC proof that their tokens are backed one-for-one. The bridge nodes stay disabled while that work continues.

Share this article
George Tsagkarakis

George Tsagkarakis, known as Staycalm4now is a professional author in the crypto gaming industry since early 2018. He has experienced all the growth of Blockchain Gaming and helped multiple projects achieve their goals and established a player base. He is the co-founder of egamers.io and now the Founder and owner of CryptoGames.gg He is also the COO of MyStage, an…

More from Cybersecurity & Privacy

Leave a Reply