Spoiler note: this is a Chapter 3 mission with three parts. It describes the choices and the ending of Halifax’s storyline.
Whether you shoot or spare Benedict Halifax at the end of Dubious Provenance, early walkthroughs say both are fine. The choice that matters more comes earlier: handing him the statue gets you a watch and keeps Parts 2 and 3 open.
We have not played the game. This guide summarises walkthroughs published on launch day. Details can differ per save, and we re-check as players report back.

Mission overview
- Mission: Dubious Provenance (Visit the Antique Store), Chapter 3, three parts.
- Becomes available: after Dealer’s Choice.
- Playable as: Lucia or Jason.
- Part 1 starts at the bag in the closet of the Bayside apartment in Vice City. Parts 2 and 3 take place in Capri, Mariana County.

Part 1: the statue
This part is required. Go to Capri by driving or using RideMe. The owner, Evelyn, refuses to appraise the statue. Her colleague Benedict Halifax offers to appraise it off the books and leaves his watch as collateral.
You can give Halifax the statue and receive the Crowex Octane “Bobby Ambrose” watch, or decline. If you decline, you can call him back later.
Part 2: the antique store and the motel
This part opens if Halifax goes silent after you give him the statue.
- Return to Evelyn Andrews Antiques.
- Sneak in through the back window, or break the door.
- Find the statue in the desk drawer.
- Search the motel next door, then decide whether to trust Halifax. Trusting him is needed for Part 3.
Part 3: the chase
Evelyn calls with an address. You chase Halifax by seashark, boat, on foot and by bike. He pepper-sprays Jason. As Lucia you shoot him in the leg using focus, call Jason, then choose to shoot or spare him. Both are reported as fine.
Rewards and consequences
- The Crowex Octane watch: equip it from a wardrobe under Accessories, then Watches.
- About $2,500 in jewellery and cash from the storage container.
- A ’32 Hustler car, which you can keep or sell.
No bugs have been reported.
Tips and pitfalls
- If you want the whole mission, do not ignore the optional prompt to call Halifax. It disappears at the end of Chapter 3.
- Trust Halifax at the motel, since Part 3 depends on it.
- Missing Parts 2 and 3 does not block the story. It only costs you the extra money.
- Wear the watch from a wardrobe afterwards. It is not equipped automatically.
The Chapter 3 setting
The mission spans two counties of the game world. Part 1 begins in Vice City at the Bayside apartment, and the later parts move to Capri in Mariana County. That means a drive or a RideMe trip between parts. Because Part 2 and Part 3 hang on a prompt that expires at the end of the chapter, finish the optional call before moving on to the next main story beats.
About this guide
GTA 6 launches on 19 November 2026 for PS5 and Xbox Series X|S, and no PC date has been announced. Every mission fact here comes from walkthroughs posted at launch, and the game is days old, so some details may be corrected. Random-looking values and small choices can vary per save. If you see something different on your own copy, trust the screen over this page.
FAQ
Should you give Halifax the statue in Dubious Provenance?
Yes, if you want the Crowex Octane watch and the later parts of the mission. Giving him the statue in Part 1 earns the watch. You can also decline and call him back later.
Should you shoot or spare Halifax at the end?
Either works. The walkthroughs say both are fine.
Can you miss the rest of Dubious Provenance?
Yes. If you ignore the optional call-Halifax prompt, it disappears at the end of Chapter 3, and Parts 2 and 3 are lost. The story still moves on, but you miss the extra money.
Free crypto, NFTs & new crypto games, before everyone else
Airdrops, free games and launches the day they drop. One email, no spam, unsubscribe anytime.








